Dissovet D 504.001.02 surrounded himself with a veil of secrecy the day before the meeting of the degree of deprivation Nikiforov. June 21 correspondent Department of Science “Gazety.Ru” tried to be accredited to the event – but the attempt failed. The same fate awaited the journalists from other publications
. <-! Place 8246189, / science / 2016/05 / 17_a_8246189.shtml, nm2015 / v2 / article / incut, incut3_link ->
On the eve of RANHiGS denied media accreditation for the event, citing a lack of beds in the room. After the intervention of the Ministry of Education and reminders about openness dissovetov revealed that modern means of communication academy still available -. The journalists took the audience with the live broadcast of the meeting
Expert “dissernet” admitted to the event itself Ivan Babitsky and first author of the statement and volunteer . Leonid Volkov
the minister Nikiforov at the meeting was not – he was that day “worked in the Trans-Baikal Territory.”
The meeting was opened by Chairman of the Board Oleg Protsenko. He mentioned that Nikiforov is now “on a mission too far”, and offered to listen to the list of claims “dissernet” to the Minister, protected in 2011.
According to “dissernet” the minister contained a number of incorrect borrowing . Because of them told on his page on facebook Leonid Volkov:
«Minister Nikiforov for six months before moving to Moscow (where he was waiting for a high position in the government) hastily Ph.D. . It found huge pieces of someone else’s text, designed so that it seemed the original text Nikiforov.
Indeed. It is clearly seen as Nikiforov systematically replaces borrowed test keyword phrases that other people came by his subjects. In the original text it is about doctors, medical institutions, medical services. Nikiforov systematically change it to officials, public institutions, state body ».
About the twentieth minute of the meeting gathered began to actively praising Minister thesis. For example, in response to allegations that the Minister has made a series of loans from its own thesis research supervisor, Professor MSTU NE Bauman Oleg Melnikov shouted into the microphone: “He develops his supervisor thought! What’s wrong with that »
During the meeting heard such phrases:” We as a dissertation council emphasize scientific personality Nikiforov, “” All great discoveries do not exist in a vacuum, and often stem from the achievements of predecessors ” “We have Marconi and Popov. Someone who there is more take – history will judge »,
« One day, I met with one of the most famous physicists, and he told me: “The main thing is you have to be a little crazy develop some new thought … “Nikiforov just develops a new idea!»
Minister called “creative,” “talented,” “enthusiastic”, “interesting.»
After a half hour voting took place – unanimously it decided to leave Nikiforov candidate of economic sciences. A few minutes before the start of voting, some council members have expressed the following thought:
probably copied not Nikiforov from other authors and other writers (one of which defended two years earlier the Minister) encroached on the work of the Minister
«In my opinion, the decision of the Board was not objective, – said the correspondent of the department of science Ivan Babitsky. – Nikiforov after all, so to speak, is accused not only in the fact that in his work there are borrowings from foreign dissertations. It is not just the same as many consecutive pages – there is systematically replaced with the words “health care services” (in Sosnowski) on ‘public services’. In general, in such cases, at the meetings dissovetov always say the same thing: scientific discoveries are always on something is based. But something based – does not mean to write off 20 pages without reference to the source and using the “AutoCorrect” feature
.
No comments:
Post a Comment